Skip to content
Free delivery over $60

Bookshop News

How we choose a staff pick

Would you spend your own money buying this book for someone else?

A Staff Pick at Readership has to pass one deliberately difficult test: would you spend your own money buying this book for someone else?

We like this rule because it keeps the recommendation personal. Saying a book is good is easy enough. Choosing it for someone else means you trust your own taste and feel confident enough to pass that book on.

There are plenty of books we admire without feeling that strongly about them. A novel can be beautifully written, widely praised or hugely popular and still not be something we would personally give to someone. Sometimes a book is impressive but does not stay with you. Sometimes you enjoy it, finish it, and move on.

The books that become Staff Picks tend to linger a little longer. It might be the writing, a character, an idea, or simply the feeling the book leaves behind. Often the sign is that you start thinking about who else might enjoy it.

We also do not expect everyone at Readership to agree on the same books. One person might love quiet literary fiction, another might read mostly crime, and someone else might have a weakness for sprawling fantasy, romance, strange memoirs, or books full of people making terrible decisions.

That variety is important to us because recommendations become more useful when you understand the person behind them. Over time, we hope readers begin to recognise individual people on our team and get a sense of whose taste lines up with their own.

If someone’s recommendations keep working for you, you can visit their bookshelf and see what else they are reading, loving and recommending. Sometimes you might find someone with very similar taste. Other times, you might end up following someone who regularly introduces you to books you would never have picked up yourself.

For that to work, the recommendations need to stay honest.

A bestseller does not automatically become a Staff Pick, and neither does a major new release or an award winner. Those things might bring a book to our attention, but they are not enough on their own. What matters is that someone here read it, liked it enough to recommend it, and was willing to put their name next to that recommendation.

That is also why Staff Picks come with a few words from the person who chose them. It is not meant to be a formal review, just a short explanation of what they liked and who they think the book might be for.

So if you are not sure what to read next, one place to start is with the people. Find someone on the Readership team whose taste seems close to yours, browse their picks, and take a look through their bookshelf. Over time, the hope is that you find a few people whose recommendations you trust and keep coming back to.