Skip to content
Free delivery over $60

Essays

Why we still need bookshops

Algorithms are very good at telling you what you already like. If you read three murder mysteries, your feed will happily offer you thirty more. If you linger over one romantasy title, suddenly every recommendation seems to involve enemies becoming lovers somewhere near a dragon.

And honestly, that can be useful. Sometimes you know exactly what you want. You want another book that gives you the same feeling as the last one, just with different characters and a different cover. Algorithms are brilliant at recognising patterns like that.

But there is another kind of book discovery that is much harder to predict.

It happens when you walk into a bookshop without really looking for anything. You pick up a book because the cover catches your eye, then notice the handwritten card underneath it. Someone has written, I couldn't stop thinking about this for days. That is enough to make you turn it over and read the back.

Maybe it isn't a genre you normally read. Maybe you've never heard of the author. Maybe, according to everything your reading history knows about you, this book should never have crossed your path at all.

You buy it anyway. And every now and then, it becomes one of your favourite books.

That is one of the reasons we still need bookshops. Not because algorithms are bad at recommendations, they are often remarkably good at them, but because most recommendation systems begin with a version of you that already exists. You liked this, therefore you might like that.

A good bookseller can do something slightly different. They can say, “I know you said you don't read science fiction, but trust me.” And that tiny sentence contains something that is difficult to reduce to a recommendation score: judgement.

Not just correlation. Not just popularity. Taste.

The best booksellers aren't simply people who know a lot of books. Over time, they build these strange little maps between readers and stories. Someone who loves a quiet Japanese novel might also love a memoir about loneliness. Someone who normally reads crime might unexpectedly enjoy a historical novel because the tension works in exactly the same way. Someone who insists they hate fantasy might discover that what they actually hate is one particular kind of fantasy.

Those connections aren't always obvious, which is exactly why they're interesting.

There is also something wonderfully inefficient about browsing a bookshop. You wander around. You read the first page of something you will never buy. You notice a book on a table because somebody decided it deserved to be there. You overhear another reader recommending something. You leave with the book you came for and, somehow, two others you had absolutely no intention of buying.

Online shopping has spent years trying to remove friction from buying things. Search, click, checkout. The fewer obstacles between wanting something and purchasing it, the better.

Books are a little different.

Sometimes the wandering is part of the experience.

We don't always arrive knowing what we're looking for, and that's part of what makes discovering a book feel special. Sometimes we want to be surprised. Sometimes we want someone else to notice a connection we would never have made ourselves.

And that doesn't necessarily have to disappear just because more of our reading lives have moved online.

The interesting question isn't whether an online bookshop can recreate rows of shelves. It's whether it can recreate discovery. Can it have opinions? Can you find a bookseller whose taste you trust and follow what they're reading? Can readers convince each other to try something outside their usual genre, argue about an ending, or recommend a strange little book that would otherwise disappear beneath the bestsellers?

Can a digital shelf feel like it was arranged by a person rather than sorted by sales rank?

We think it can.

Because maybe what people love about great bookshops was never only the room itself. It was the people inside it. The handwritten recommendation. The conversation at the counter. The table of books somebody cared enough to put together.

Most of all, it was the feeling that somewhere among all those stories was one you didn't yet know you needed.

Algorithms will keep getting better at understanding what we like.

Bookshops, we hope, will keep introducing us to what we don't.